According to Penn State’s official account, the “We Are” chant originated during the 1976 football season, and by 1981 it had become a permanent part of their games. So, the timeline for the long chant evolving into a back-and-forth chant across Mountaineer Field seems to line up.
Joe Swan even says, “To me, it’s reminiscent of the ‘We Are …. Penn State’ chant. I just don’t know if that was the inspiration or not.”
But fear not, Redmond has an explanation:
“When we moved to the new stadium, people tried to do the old cheer. But the stadium was too big. And they couldn't hear each other, if that makes any sense. They couldn't get themselves coordinated, so it never worked. So unfortunately, what happened at New Mountaineer Field is we started doing a cheer that was very similar to what Penn State does. Of course, we don't like Penn State.
“So, one side says, ‘We are’ and the other side says ‘Penn State.’ And a lot of our fans, I think, had been up there or maybe experienced that. So rather than a long, ‘Let's Goooooo Mountaineers’ cheer, it ended up going [side to side] because they couldn't hear each other. It became a side-to-side thing with ‘Let's Go!’ on one side and ‘Mountaineers’ on the other. And we old-timers, we hated that.”
But the original version lived on elsewhere. Redmond adds, “The WVU Coliseum opened in 1970. And the new football stadium opened in 1980. So, the first years of the Coliseum, the first 10 years, we were doing the old, ‘Let's Goooooo Mountaineers’ in the Coliseum, and it worked fine in there. Because everybody's close. You can hear other people. But for some reason, once it started to disappear at football games, we lost it in [the Coliseum] too.”
Greg Hunter feels that the version with opposite sides of the stadium calling and responding is less emotional, but that none are derived from “We Are … Penn State”: “The version I think of definitely is not copied off of that.” So there.